Opinion Blog: Deceit Reveals Need in Afghanistan, Pakistan

May 13, 2011  

Posted by Sydni Brass
sbrass@smu.edu

Three or Four Cups of Tea?

In 1993 Greg Mortenson failed attempt to climb K2, the second-tallest mountain in the world. The experience gave him the resolve for a greater achievement and he took it upon himself to build schools in regions of Pakistan and Afghanistan.

His memoir, “Three Cups of Tea,” details the obstacles he faced and emphasizes a favorable outcome. Consequently, it spent 220 weeks on the bestseller list.

Mortenson was hailed as a hero for his accomplishments… until now.

Recently, Mortenson was accused of fabricating key elements of his experience in the Himalayas and of misusing the funds he raised with his organization, the Central Asian Institute (CAI), after donors began to realize the numbers didn’t match up.

The newsmagazine “60 Minutes” covered the topic in a report last month and author Jon Krakauer (Into Thin Air) followed up the report with a 75-page manuscript entitled “Three Cups of Deceit,” available on byliner.com.

The controversy surrounding his fundraising efforts to promote education overseas, the issue is garnering adverse attention. However, the need for schooling in the Middle East is legitimate, whether Mortenson’s accounts are or not.

He may not have followed through with his plan, but he certainly spread a message to a mass audience.

In his “memoir,” Mortenson stresses that schools are the greatest weapons of war and that education abroad promotes peace. Schools certainly won’t put an end to war and terrorism, but they are a step in the right direction.

So is Mortenson the thief he is made out to be by recent reports? Probably. Did he do more harm than help? Maybe.

He conned a lot of good people out of their hard-earned money and he should be publically humiliated (as is happening now). However, we should continue his message and his claimed plan of action.

After all, the children of Afghanistan and Pakistan did not deceive CAI donors. They should not get the shaft because someone, with the intent (or maybe distant dream) of helping, was found to be a fraud.

Enter Google AdSense Code Here

Comments

3 Responses to “Opinion Blog: Deceit Reveals Need in Afghanistan, Pakistan”

  1. Senge Sering on May 13th, 2011 3:29 pm

    Please visit http://www.gilgitbaltistan.us to learn more about the region where Mortenson started his school projects. We the natives of Gilgit-Baltistan, a region of former princely state of Jammu and Kashmir do have lot of respect for him for providing education to girls in that area. The region has one of the lowest per capita incomes and one of the lowest literacy rates and without support of NGOs like CAI and AKDN, education would be a dream for the majority as more than half of the locals live below the poverty line. Since Pakistan government has failed to provide for the educational needs of the people of Gilgit-Baltistan, it is people like Mortenson who became the hope for us

  2. PJ Hunter on May 13th, 2011 10:29 pm

    Why do you sound like he has already been tried and convicted? jUST CURIOUS.

  3. Julia Bergman on May 14th, 2011 7:07 pm

    The one-sided allegations made by Jon Krakauer and 60 Minutes constitute a character assassination again Greg Mortenson, a very compassionate and brave man, an honorable man of personal and professional integrity.

    Dozens of articles and blogs have appeared in recent weeks simply rephrasing and rehashing Krakauer’s piece of misleading half truths and manipulation of facts.

    For the truth, go to: http://www.ikat.org where Greg has posted responses to the allegations.